Michael Loccisano / Getty Images

“I was taken aback the moment I saw Olivia Thirlby,” Elliot reportedly wrote in his memoir, Pageboy. He and Olivia were the same age at the time, but he said, to him, Olivia seemed “so much older, capable, and centered” than him — “sexually open, far removed from where I was at the time. But the chemistry was palpable, it pulled me in.”